1. Didja accidentally blow through the whole, "We're using our real names" thing on registration? No problem, just send me (Mike) a Conversation message and I'll get you sorted, by which I mean hammered-into-obedient-line because I'm SO about having a lot of individuality-destroying, oppressive shit all over my forum.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. You're only as good as the harshest criticism you're willing to hear.
    Dismiss Notice

Ryan Otter - Les Magic

Discussion in 'Critique & Feedback' started by Ryan Rubinstein, Feb 9, 2019.

  1. Okay,
    After Mike's roasted me on tonight's Comp4 class,I ought to post some of my music)
    But anyway,Its my first post here...havent use forums for ,like, 10 years. Where can I introduce myself and write more about what help/suggestions I seek (in Mike's classes mostly and here),is this thread a good place or there is specific room for rookies ?)

    Anyway,welcome a new member)

    1.
    2. (with godfarts. our favorites)
    3. https://www.dropbox.com/s/x1lesh7b6ai4skw/Ryan Otter G07 Bastarduk 7EP Fire #3 (final).mp3?dl=0
     
    Rohann van Rensburg likes this.
  2. This is as good a place as any. We don't seem to have ongoing threads, most people just start new ones. Welcome, by the way; this is a pretty awesome place with some fantastically helpful, skilled composers commenting on the regular (not me ;) ).
     
  3. Thanks Rohann!
    So,as a prequel to my questions will be small background.

    I was never tought how to read or write music,as a result I have absolutely no ability to read or write scores. I never attended to musical school,nor had a teacher,never learned any instrument "properly" - but somehow I was very interested in music and gradually started to learn everything on my own. I came to "composing" or simply write my own music from sound engineering and I can write a tune or two (or twenty)),but as you can hear ,I suck at a piano and my overall "knowing" about how to write music reminds me a fundament, but with lots of holes,as a colander))
    @Mike mentioned - "forget the theory,just write" - well,its even easier ,I never had one) And I always write everything that I wrote from the heart and by ear.
    BUT
    I feel like I amd touching the ceiling of my abilities and wanted to learn/extend skills - whatever thats works. Push the boundaries,If you will. And then I stumbled across Mike's classes somewhere in the internet,and man - this man explain everything in plain language.
    Thats a short story
     
    Rohann van Rensburg likes this.
  4. Hi Ryan, Welcome to the forum. What do you want to know about your pieces? And yes, you can post your pieces here and get some feedback.
     
  5. Indeed! You're on the same page as many here.

    Have you taken the first Comp classes? I found "Structure" particularly useful as well. He also has a great YouTube video on transcription, if you haven't seen it.
     
  6. I will post a few more ,If nobody minds...
    These few are from scenes from movie,with dialogs,but I like how mood is changing and evolving (even not in JW way of evolving,thats a complete magic for me yet))
    https://www.dropbox.com/s/calshd6luf2pdql/Ryan Otter Trockii Freud #1.mp3?dl=0
    https://www.dropbox.com/s/t5ge0fttprg1kcn/Ryan Otter Trockii Parvus Talk #1.mp3?dl=0
    https://www.dropbox.com/s/iw2zq9i308x8h9n/Ryan Otter G08 Jenny 3 (dub) 4-2 (08.44.09.20).mp3?dl=0



    to Rohann:
    Yes,I've seen Comp1-3,very-very much hyped about Comp4; I've purchased a lot of classes already and some of them are on repeat already,some of them (like all that jazz I simply couldnt digest,so I will take place later)
    I found structure very useful, Mod Squad and Theminator were most fulfilling;

    to Alexander
    Well,I do work on the gigs and as they are mostly half-Zimmerish task,half who knows what, I would like to understand and extend my skills to conquer that Adventure sound. Of 80s. or of 90s)) whatever) Right now,John William's stuff sounds like complete magic to me,so much is going on and roots are in the symphonic pieces,which is hard to understand on your own. A year ago ,action scenes with different 5/8 etc measures was a complete mystery to me and now,with help of classes and work I kind of do get them. But directors never asked me for John Williams stuff - nor could I possibly provide - thats just for me. I believe,understanding Horner/Silvestri/Goldsmith (I took those classes,very insteresting,mostly because the stuff turns out to be simple) - understanding them will extend vocabulary ,and even if the task is to make 90min of Jason Bourne music,I could implement something different in it. Thats my goal at least.

    So,if to sum it up,I can do what I do and you can hear the level. I want to learn,how to go places from there.
     
    Rohann van Rensburg likes this.
  7. As far as piano skills go -- I found a few months (once a week) of jazz lessons helped demystify the piano. Seeing chords, extensions, inversions, etc comes a lot more easily now.
     
  8. Okay, I am not anymore today at my piano, but maybe tomorrow / next days I will record something, though I will stick to your first track you posted and give you some thoughts.
     
    Ryan Rubinstein likes this.
  9. Yeah,I do sit at piano more and more and see/print chords more and more ,this certainly helps
     

Share This Page